The Energy Tax: why you guess instead of looking it up

By Kevin Hughes, founder of Inkteract · Published

The small physical chores of a long read, and why they change how you read.

The small chores of a long read

You’re reading a long report in your browser, and a little number sends you to the endnotes. You scroll down, read the note, scroll back up, and look for the line you left. None of it is hard, and you’ll do it again in four paragraphs.

That’s the Energy Tax: the physical chore of working a page while you read it. Each one is small. Together, they add up.

Research suggests they change how you read, not only how tired you feel. Inkteract is a Chrome extension we’re building to skip those chores. It puts the answer near the word, so your hand and eyes stay on the sentence.

What the Energy Tax is

The Energy Tax is the physical effort of working a page. Scrolling, dragging, highlighting, right-clicking, and moving your eyes off the text to a sidebar or another tab all count.

It’s one of eight costs we cover. The other seven:

  • Time Tax. The minutes lost to lookups and rereading, like opening a new tab to define a word.
  • Thinking Tax. Friction on the page that pulls effort away from understanding what you read.
  • Attention Tax. The work of staying inside the text when the page around it is busy.
  • Visual Tax. The stall when you meet something you can’t picture, like an astrolabe.
  • Prerequisite Tax. The fog that comes from missing context: an idiom, a technical term, a piece of jargon.
  • Trust and Safety Tax. The effort of wondering whether a source or headline can be trusted.
  • Emotional Tax. The energy it takes to stay focused when the subject is heavy.

Where you pay the Energy Tax

  • The footnote trip. Notes at the bottom of the page or the end of the article mean a scroll down, a scroll back, and a hunt for your line.
  • The highlight-and-search. Drag across a word, right-click, pick search, wait for a new tab, then come back. That’s five steps for one small question.
  • The acronym hunt. 10 paragraphs after an acronym was spelled out, you’ve forgotten it. So you scroll up to find where it first appeared.
  • The sidebar glance. A definition or a “related” box sits off to the side. Your eyes leave the sentence, read the box, and have to find the line again.

What the research says

Nobody has measured the Energy Tax as one number. But researchers have studied its two parts: what small physical costs do to behavior, and what happens when an answer sits away from the question.

The first comes from cognitive scientists Wayne Gray and Wai-Tat Fu. In a 2004 lab study, people could check the right information on screen, but only after a click to uncover it.

Often they didn’t bother. They worked from memory instead, and made more mistakes.

Their conclusion is short.

“The results suggest that milliseconds matter.”

In plain words, when checking costs even a little effort, people trust their memory over the screen. Their task wasn’t reading, but the pattern will look familiar to anyone who has skipped a footnote. When the answer is a few moves away, you’re more likely to guess.

The second part is what learning researchers call split attention. John Sweller, Jeroen van Merriënboer and Fred Paas define it this way.

“Split attention occurs when learners are confronted with two complementary sources of information, which cannot stand on their own but must be integrated before they can be understood.”

A word and its definition are that kind of pair: neither is much use alone. A 2018 meta-analysis (a study that pools the results of many studies) by Noah Schroeder and Ada Cenkci pooled 58 comparisons and found people learn more when related words and pictures sit close together.

Hamideh Marefat, Abbas Ali Rezaee and Farid Naserieh tested the idea on reading. Learners of English read a text where each definition, called a gloss, was shown either in the text at the word or out in the margin.

Readers who got the definition near the word reported less mental strain and scored higher on comprehension. The study determined that the closer the answer, the easier the read.

What it costs you

On its own, the Energy Tax is easy to pay. One trip to the endnotes costs a few seconds and a little effort. The trouble is that it rarely comes alone.

Take a dense journal article you need for a literature review, open on the journal’s website:

  • In the introduction: an acronym that was spelled out in the abstract. Until you know what it stands for, you can’t follow what the text is saying, which is the Thinking Tax. So you scroll up to find it, then scroll back and hunt for your line.
  • In the background section: a key claim with a numbered citation. You want to know whose work it is before you believe it, which is the Trust and Safety Tax. So it’s off to the reference list at the end and back again.
  • In the methods: a piece of lab equipment you’ve never seen. You can’t picture it, which is the Visual Tax, so you open a new tab to look it up.
  • In the results: a term from a field next to yours that you don’t quite know, which is the Prerequisite Tax. You highlight it, search it, and come back.

None of these stops is hard. But they stack up, and each one pulls you out of what you’re reading for a moment. Somewhere in the discussion section, you skip a citation or guess at a term instead of looking it up.

What Inkteract does about it

Inkteract keeps the answer where your eyes already are. Hover over a word for a moment and a faint Ghost Icon appears. Click the Ghost Icon, and a small card opens near the text you’re reading.

What that does for each reading tax:

  • Smart Footnote Converter. Read a footnote or citation right where it’s marked. No scroll to the bottom, and no hunt for your line on the way back.
  • Single Word Definition. The meaning appears near the word, in the visual field of your sentence.
  • Smart Acronym Converter. 10 paragraphs or 50 pages later, the full term appears right above the text. No scrolling up to find where it was spelled out.
  • Ghost Icons. Nothing is added to the page until you hover, and the card opens under your line instead of in a sidebar. Your eyes don’t have to travel to get the answer.

There’s more on the card when you need it: a dense sentence rewritten in plain English, or a long paragraph summed up in a few bullets.

The point is simple: when the answer is right there, looking it up is easier than guessing.

None of these chores is worth a complaint on its own. That’s how they get away with it.

If you’d rather keep your hand and eyes on the sentence, join the Inkteract waitlist. And if the Energy Tax sounds familiar, the other seven are in the full Reading Tax guide.

Sources

  1. Wayne D. Gray and Wai-Tat Fu, “Soft constraints in interactive behavior: the case of ignoring perfect knowledge in-the-world for imperfect knowledge in-the-head,” Cognitive Science, 2004. Link
  2. John Sweller, Jeroen J. G. van Merriënboer, and Fred Paas, “Cognitive Architecture and Instructional Design: 20 Years Later,” Educational Psychology Review, 2019. Link
  3. Noah L. Schroeder and Ada T. Cenkci, “Spatial Contiguity and Spatial Split-Attention Effects in Multimedia Learning Environments: a Meta-Analysis,” Educational Psychology Review, 2018. Link
  4. Hamideh Marefat, Abbas Ali Rezaee, and Farid Naserieh, “Effect of Computerized Gloss Presentation Format on Reading Comprehension: A Cognitive Load Perspective,” Journal of Information Technology Education: Research, 2016. Link
Next postThe Thinking Tax: what you hold in your head while you read
  • Energy Tax