The Thinking Tax: what you hold in your head while you read
By Kevin Hughes, founder of Inkteract · Published
Reading is prep work and cooking. Both are thinking, and the prep comes first.

Back to the top of the paragraph
You’re halfway through a paper, and an idea starts to form: this point might explain a problem in your own work. To check, you need to be sure what the authors mean by one term, so you look it up and come back.
Your sentence is still there, but the sentence-lookup detour made you forget your mental place. Now, you’re sussing out the meaning of the word and trying to recombine it with your sentence.
That’s the Thinking Tax: the mental work of reading itself. Inkteract is a Chrome extension built to keep the answer near the sentence, so there’s less to rebuild when you come back.
What the Thinking Tax is, and what it costs you
The Thinking Tax is the mental work of reading itself. Think of it as making a meal. Prep work is the mental chopping and measuring, like working out whether “he” refers to Andy or Jim, or recalling what an acronym defined three pages back stands for.
Cooking is putting those pieces together: deciding what the paper shows, whether you believe it, and what it means for your own work. Both are thinking, and you can’t skip either. But prep comes first, so the longer it takes, the less attention is left for the cooking.
One bit of prep is small. The cost comes when it piles up: an unfamiliar term early on, a claim you’re not sure you believe, a phrase near the end that could point to either of two findings. You can follow every paragraph and still finish with a weaker grasp of the paper as a whole.
It’s one of eight costs we cover in the Reading Tax guide.
Where you pay the Thinking Tax
- The question you carry. A result raises a question, like whether it holds for the smaller sample. You keep reading with that question in your head, half-following the text, until you find the answer or forget the question.
- The ambiguous reference. “This effect” could mean either of two findings in the paragraph. You weigh which one the authors mean before you can judge their next claim.
- The dense sentence. One sentence carries four clauses and two qualifications. You work out which part qualifies which before you can tell what the authors are actually claiming.
What the research says
Psychologists don’t call it the Thinking Tax, but two lines of their research match its two parts. One looks at what happens when readers have to hold something in mind while they read. The other looks at what happens when the text itself is hard to process.
Start with holding a thought. Psychologists Kit W. Cho, Jeanette Altarriba and Maximilian Popiel asked when doing two things at once actually hurts reading. In their first experiment, breaking off from a passage to answer trivia questions or solve math problems made no measurable difference to comprehension. In their second, readers had to keep a string of numbers in mind while they read, and the result changed.
“Performance on the reading comprehension test was lower in the cognitive load conditions relative to the no-load condition.”
In plain words, readers who were holding something in their heads understood less of what they read. In the study, it was a string of numbers. In a paper, it’s the open question you carry while you keep reading. So the cost in this study came less from leaving the text than from what readers had to hold in mind while reading it.
Now the effort of processing hard text. Olivia Bullock and colleagues had 650 people read about new technologies, written with or without jargon.
“We find that the presence of jargon impairs people’s ability to process scientific information, and that this impairment leads to greater motivated resistance to persuasion, increased risk perceptions, and lower support for technology adoption.”
In plain words, when a text is harder to process, readers don’t just slow down. They also trust it less. For anyone reading a paper outside their own field, that’s worth knowing: the effort of decoding unfamiliar language can affect how much you trust what you read, not only how fast you read it.
What Inkteract does about the Thinking Tax
Inkteract does much of the prep work for you, so more of your thinking goes to the cooking. Hover over a word for a moment and a faint Ghost Icon appears. Click it, and a small card opens near the text you’re reading.
Here’s the prep it takes over:
- Smart Pronoun Converter. Shows whether “he” means Andy or Jim, so you don’t have to work it out from the sentences before.
- Smart Measurement Converter. Turns “5 miles” into kilometers or “2 gallons” into liters, so you don’t have to do the math in your head while you read.
- Sentence Explainer. Rewrites a dense sentence in plain English, so you can see which part qualifies which before you judge the claim.
It won’t do the cooking for you, and it shouldn’t. But with less prep on every page, you have more thinking left for learning.
If you’d rather keep your train of thought, join the Inkteract waitlist. And if the Thinking Tax sounds familiar, the other seven are in the Reading Tax guide.
Sources
- Kit W. Cho, Jeanette Altarriba, and Maximilian Popiel, “Mental juggling: when does multitasking impair reading comprehension?” The Journal of General Psychology, 2015. Link
- Olivia M. Bullock, Daniel Colón Amill, Hillary C. Shulman, and Graham N. Dixon, “Jargon as a barrier to effective science communication: Evidence from metacognition,” Public Understanding of Science, 2019. Link
- Thinking Tax